All Star Ratings

Filter by

Star Rating

5 Star rated

  • 1st Central

    Private Car Legal

  • 1st Central

    Private Car Plus (incl. Breakdown)

  • 1st Central

    Private Car Premier

  • Admiral

    Car Insurance

  • Admiral

    LittleBox

  • Admiral

    MultiCar

  • AXA Direct

    Car Insurance

  • Bell

    plug and drive

  • Diamond

    Car Insurance

  • Elephant

    Car Insurance

  • Hastings Direct

    Car Insurance

  • Hastings Direct

    Premier Car Insurance

  • Hedgehog

    Premier Private Car Policy

  • Hedgehog

    Private Car Policy

  • Insurepink

    Car Insurance

  • LV=

    Car Insurance

  • LV=

    Car Insurance (Boundless by CSMA)

  • NFU Mutual

    Car Policy

  • NFU Mutual

    Car Policy (Bespoke)

  • People's Choice

    Car Insurance

  • Smartdriverclub Insurance

    Private Car Powerpoint (393) (Aviva)

4 Star rated

  • 1st Central

    Private Car

  • AA

    Car Insurance (Members)

  • AA

    Car Insurance (Members) (Comparison Site)

  • AA

    Car Insurance (Non Members)

  • AA

    Car Insurance (Non Members) (Comparison Site)

  • Age Co

    Car Insurance

  • AXA Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • AXA Insurance

    Car Plus

  • Budget Insurance Services

    Private Car Policy

  • Churchill

    Car Insurance

  • Churchill

    Car Insurance (Comparison Site)

  • Churchill

    DriveSure Car Insurance

  • Citroen Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Dial Direct

    Car Insurance

  • Dial Direct

    Premier Car Insurance

  • esure

    Car Insurance

  • First Alternative

    Car Insurance

  • Geoffrey Insurance Services

    Car Insurance

  • Halifax

    Car Insurance

  • Hastings Direct SmartMiles

    Car Insurance

  • iGO4 Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • iGO4 Insurance

    More Insurance

  • MORE TH>N

    Car Insurance

  • Nissan Insurance

    Private Car (Covea Insurance)

  • Post Office Money

    Premier Car Insurance

  • RAC

    Black Box Car Insurance

  • RAC

    Car Insurance

  • RSA

    Drive (Cornmarket)

  • RSA

    Drive (Sutton Winson)

  • Saga

    Motor Insurance Saga Car

  • Sainsbury's Bank

    Car Insurance

  • Sainsbury's Bank

    Car Plus

  • Sheilas' Wheels

    Car Insurance

  • Smartdriverclub Insurance

    Car Insurance (63491) (Covea)

  • Tesco Bank

    Car Insurance (Direct)

3 Star rated

  • Allianz

    Car Insurance (NI only)

  • Aviva

    Home & Drivers Club

  • Aviva

    Motor Insurance

  • Aviva

    MultiCar Insurance

  • Aviva

    Private Car Policy (powerpoint & e-Services)

  • AXA

    Car Insurance (NI only)

  • AXA

    Drivesave (NI Only)

  • Bank of Scotland

    Car Insurance

  • Brightside

    Brightside Car Insurance

  • Broker Direct

    CarCare (10)

  • Broker Direct

    CarCare (12.5)

  • Broker Direct

    CarCare (7.5)

  • Broker Direct

    Private Car (Provide)

  • Carole Nash

    Six Wheel Insurance

  • Carrot Insurance

    Better Driver (Aviva)

  • Carrot Insurance

    Better Driver (Aviva) (Comparison Site)

  • Carrot Insurance

    Better Driver (Zurich)

  • Carrot Insurance

    New Driver (Aviva)

  • Carrot Insurance

    New Driver (Aviva) (Comparison Site)

  • Carrot Insurance

    New Driver (Zurich)

  • Clegg Gifford & Co

    HomeFleet (Tradex)

  • Cornish Mutual

    Private Motor Vehicle Insurance

  • Covea Insurance plc

    Private Car

  • Debenhams

    Car Insurance (Highway)

  • Debenhams

    Private Car Insurance (Watford Re)

  • Direct Line

    Car Insurance

  • Direct Line

    DrivePlus Car Insurance

  • Endsleigh

    Endsleigh Loop (Prof fitted)

  • Endsleigh

    Endsleigh Loop (self fitted)

  • Endsleigh

    Motor Policy

  • Endsleigh

    Plus Motor Policy

  • ERS

    car

  • First Underwriting

    First Car

  • General Accident

    Car Insurance

  • Go Girl

    Private Car Insurance

  • Goskippy Insurance

    Private Car Insurance (Watford Re)

  • Haven Insurance Company Ltd

    Private Car Insurance Plus

  • Hughes Insurance

    Car Insurance (NI only)

  • Hughes Insurance

    HughesDrive (NI Only)

  • iGO4 Insurance

    Essential Insurance

  • Insure 2 Drive

    Private Car Insurance

  • KGM Motor Insurance

    High Net Worth Motor Insurance

  • Kitsune Associates

    Car Insurance

  • Lifesure Group

    Motor Insurance (40+)

  • Lloyds Bank

    Car Insurance

  • LV= Broker

    Highway Bespoke Car and Telematic insurance

  • M&S Bank

    Premier Car Insurance

  • M&S Bank

    Standard Car Insurance

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Family Marque Enhance (ZM)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Family Marque Exceed (ZM)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Family Marque Expect (ZM)

  • Marmalade

    black box insurance

  • MCE Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Nissan Insurance

    Motor Guard (Ageas)

  • Nissan Insurance

    Optima Car (Ageas)

  • Nissan Insurance

    Private Car (MHR) (MISL)

  • Onequote Direct Elite

    Private Car (Europa Elite)

  • Peugeot Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Police Mutual

    Car Insurance

  • Police Mutual

    Family Car

  • Post Office Money

    Car Insurance (Comparison Site)

  • Post Office Money

    Car Insurance (CTM & Moneysupermarket)

  • Post Office Money

    Over 50s Car Insurance

  • Post Office Money

    Under 50s Car Insurance

  • Privilege

    Car Insurance

  • Santander

    Car Insurance

  • Smartdriverclub Insurance

    Private Car insurance (T1864) (MISL)

  • Sterling Insurance

    FluxScore Telematics Car

  • Sterling Insurance

    Learner Driver (ERS)

  • Swiftcover.com

    Car Insurance

  • Swinton

    Classic Car Insurance EMB 05 May 20

  • Tesco Bank

    Car Insurance (Comparison Site)

  • Tesco Bank

    Car Insurance Cover+

  • Vauxhall Insurance Services

    Motor Insurance

  • Vavista

    Private Car Insurance (Watford Re)

  • WiseDriving

    Intelligent Car Insurance (App)

  • WiseDriving

    Intelligent Car Insurance (App) (GoCo)

  • WiseDriving

    Intelligent Car Insurance (Black Box)

  • WiseDriving

    Intelligent Car Insurance (Black Box) (GoCo)

  • WiseDriving

    Intelligent Car Insurance (Self-Install)

  • WiseDriving

    Intelligent Car Insurance (Self-Install) (GoCo)

  • Zenith Insurance Plc

    Car Insurance

2 Star rated

  • Ageas

    Optima Car

  • Ageas

    Optima Plus

  • Autonet Insurance

    Private Car (Midas Autonet)

  • Autonet Plus

    Private Car (Midas Autonet)

  • Autonet Protect Plus

    Private Car (Midas Autonet)

  • Broker Direct

    CarLine

  • Carrot Insurance

    Better Driver (Zurich) (Comparison Site)

  • Carrot Insurance

    New Driver (Zurich) (Comparison Site)

  • Collingwood Insurance

    Bespoke Motor

  • Collingwood Insurance

    Motor Vehicle Insurance (Over 50s)

  • Collingwood Insurance

    Private Car Insurance for Learner Drivers

  • CSIS

    Car Solutions Insurance

  • Footman James

    Multi Vehicle Motor Insurance

  • Haven Insurance Company Ltd

    Private Car Telematics

  • Key Choice

    SoteriaDrive

  • LV= Broker

    Highway Car Insurance

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Auto-Marque (ZM)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Distinction Private Car (MISL)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Private Car (Distinction IHR) (ZI)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Private Car (MHR)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Private Car Insurance (ZI)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Telematics Insurance Policy (MISL)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Telematics Insurance Policy (ZI)

  • Octane Underwriting

    Motor Insurance

  • One Call Insurance Services

    Private Car insurance (XS Direct) (£1000 Excess)

  • One Call Insurance Services

    Private Car insurance (XS Direct) (£1500 Excess)

  • One Call Insurance Services

    Private Car insurance (XS Direct) (£3000 Excess)

  • Sabre

    Private Car Insurance

  • Sabre

    Private Car Insurance (Telematics)

  • Trinity Lane Insurance Company

    Trinity Lane Motor Vehicle

  • Zurich

    Car Solutions Insurance (Broker)

1 Star rated

  • Ageas

    Motor Guard

  • Be Wiser

    Learner Driver (KGM) (Be Wiser)

  • China Taiping Insurance

    Private Car Insurance

  • Countrywide

    Motor Guard

  • Haven Insurance Company Ltd

    Private Car Insurance

  • Insenture Underwriting

    Private Car Insurance

  • KGM Motor Insurance

    2Infinity Multi Vehicle Insurance

  • KGM Motor Insurance

    Private Car Insurance

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Private Car Insurance (MISL)

  • Markerstudy Insurance Services

    Solar Distinction Private Car (MISL)

  • Midas Underwriting

    Executive Car Insurance (NI only)

  • Midas Underwriting

    Premier Car Insurance (NI only)

  • Midas Underwriting

    Private Car

  • Mulsanne Insurance

    Private Car

  • Mulsanne Insurance

    Telematics Private Car Insurance

  • Park Home Assist Insurance Services Ltd

    Private Car

  • Peter James Insurance

    Motor Vehicle Insurance

  • Premier Underwriting Ltd

    Premier PICL Private Car Policy

  • Watford Insurance Company Europe

    Private Car Insurance

  • XS Direct Insurance Broker Ltd

    Private Car Insurance (£1000 Excess)

  • XS Direct Insurance Broker Ltd

    Private Car Insurance (£1500 Excess)

  • XS Direct Insurance Broker Ltd

    Private Car Insurance (£3000 Excess)

  • Zurich

    Car Insurance (Broker)

Related links

   

OUR METHODOLOGY

Our Star Ratings are updated every year on 1 February. Throughout the year we review the criteria with the industry and conduct market research to set robust standards. Our ratings are published here, on our website, ensuring transparency.

 

Learn more