All Star Ratings

Filter by

Star Rating

5 Star rated

  • 1st Central

    Private Car

  • 1st Central

    Private Car Plus

  • 1st Central

    Private Car Premier

  • AA

    Car Insurance (Members)

  • AA

    Car Insurance (Members) (Comparison Site)

  • AA

    Car Insurance (Non Members)

  • AA

    Car Insurance (Non Members) (Comparison Sites)

  • AgeUK

    Car Insurance

  • Aioi Nissay Dowa Insurance Europe

    Motor Insurance

  • Alfa Romeo Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Aviva

    Home & Drivers Club

  • Aviva

    Motor Insurance

  • Aviva

    MultiCar Insurance

  • Aviva

    Private Car

  • Aviva

    Private Car Powerpoint

  • AXA Direct

    Car Insurance

  • Budget Insurance Services

    Private Car Policy

  • Churchill

    Car Insurance

  • Churchill

    DriveSure Car Insurance

  • Coutts & Co.

    Private Motor Insurance

  • Dacia Insurance

    Annual Motor Insurance

  • Debenhams

    Car Insurance (Southern Rock)

  • Debenhams

    Private Car (Aviva)

  • Debenhams

    Private Car Insurance (Watford Re)

  • Dial Direct

    Car Insurance

  • Dial Direct

    Premier Car Insurance

  • Direct Line

    Car Insurance

  • Direct Line

    DrivePlus Car Insurance

  • Direct Line

    Select Premier

  • esure

    Car Insurance

  • Fiat Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • First Alternative

    Car Insurance

  • Ford Insure

    Private Car Insurance

  • Geoffrey Insurance Services

    Car Insurance

  • Goskippy Insurance

    Private Car Insurance (Southern Rock Insurance)

  • Goskippy Insurance

    Private Car Insurance (Watford Re)

  • Hastings Direct

    Car Insurance (Policy Wording HD-PC-GW)

  • Hastings Direct

    Car Insurance (Policy Wording Ref HD-PC-CPW)

  • Hastings Direct

    Premier Car Insurance (Policy Wording HP-PC-GW)

  • Hastings Direct

    Premier Car Insurance (Policy Wording PRE-PC-CPW)

  • Hastings Direct SmartMiles

    Car Insurance

  • Highway Insurance

    Bespoke Car Insurance

  • Honda

    Honda Car Insurance

  • Hyundai Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Jaguar Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Jeep Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • John Lewis Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Kia

    Car Insurance

  • Land Rover Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Lexus Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • LV=

    Car Insurance (Boundless by CSMA)

  • LV=

    Car Insurance (Comparison Site)

  • LV=

    Car Insurance (Direct)

  • LV=

    Extra Car Insurance

  • LV=

    Plus Car Insurance

  • Mazda Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Mercedes-Benz Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • MG Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Mitsubishi

    Motor Insurance

  • MORE TH>N

    Car Insurance

  • NatWest

    Private Motor Insurance

  • NFU Mutual

    Car Policy

  • O2

    O2 Drive

  • O2

    O2 Drive 'Box on Board'

  • One Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Original Insurance

    Private Car Insurance

  • People's Choice

    Car Insurance (Reference H)

  • Police Mutual

    Family Car

  • Police Mutual

    Green Car Insurance

  • Post Office Money

    Over 50s Car Insurance

  • Post Office Money

    Premier Car Insurance (CTM & Moneysupermarket)

  • Provident Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • RAC

    Black Box Car Insurance

  • RAC

    Car Insurance Plus

  • Renault Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • RIAS

    Motor Insurance

  • Royal Bank of Scotland

    Private Motor Insurance

  • Saga

    Motor Insurance

  • Sainsbury's Bank

    Car Insurance

  • Sheilas' Wheels

    Car Insurance

  • smart

    Motor Insurance by Smart

  • SunLife

    Car Insurance

  • Suzuki Insurance Services

    Motor Insurance

  • Swinton

    Classic Car Insurance

  • Swinton

    Premier Car Insurance

  • Tesco Bank

    Car Insurance (Comparison Site)

  • Tesco Bank

    Car Insurance (Direct)

  • Tesco Bank

    Car Insurance Cover+

  • Toyota Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Volvo Car Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Zurich

    Car Solutions Insurance (Broker)

4 Star rated

  • Admiral

    LittleBox

  • Admiral

    Motor Insurance

  • Admiral

    MultiCar

  • Allianz

    Clear Private Car Insurance

  • AXA Insurance

    Car Plus

  • Bell

    Safe Driver (Plug and Drive)

  • BMW Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Brightside

    Brightside Car Insurance

  • Clydesdale Bank

    Car Insurance

  • Comfort Insurance

    Horizon Private Car Insurance

  • Co-op Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Covea Insurance plc

    Private Car

  • Coverbox

    Car Insurance (Highway)

  • Coverbox

    Private Car (Aviva)

  • Debenhams

    Car Insurance (ABC)

  • Debenhams

    Car Insurance (AXA)

  • Debenhams

    Motor Guard (Ageas)

  • Debenhams

    Private Car (Covea)

  • Diamond

    Motor Insurance

  • Elephant

    Private Car Insurance

  • General Accident

    Car Insurance

  • General Accident

    Car Insurance (Telematics)

  • Home & Legacy

    Premier Motor Insurance

  • Hughes Insurance

    Car Insurance (NI only)

  • M&S Bank

    Premier Car Insurance

  • M&S Bank

    Standard Car Insurance

  • MINI Insurance

    Mini Car Insurance

  • Nissan Insurance

    Car Insurance (Covea)

  • People's Choice

    Car Insurance (Reference XA)

  • Privilege

    DriveXpert Motor Insurance

  • Privilege

    Motor Insurance

  • Quotemehappy.com

    Car Insurance

  • RSA

    Drive (Partner)

  • RSA

    Drive (Sutton Winson)

  • Swiftcover.com

    Car Insurance

  • WiseDriving

    Intelligent Car Insurance (App)

  • WiseDriving

    Intelligent Car Insurance (Black Box)

  • Yorkshire Bank

    Car Insurance

  • Zurich

    Car Insurance (Direct)

3 Star rated

  • ABC Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Advantage Insurance Company

    Car Insurance

  • Ageas

    Motor Guard

  • Ageas

    Optima Car

  • Ageas

    Optima Plus

  • Allianz

    Car Insurance (NI only)

  • Audi Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • AXA

    Car Insurance (NI only)

  • AXA

    Drivesave (NI Only)

  • AXA Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Bank of Scotland

    Car Insurance

  • Bradford & Bingley

    Private Car (Comparison Site)

  • Bradford & Bingley

    Private Car (Direct)

  • Broker Direct

    Private Car (Provide)

  • Broker Direct

    Private Car (Urban)

  • Carole Nash

    Six Wheel Insurance

  • Citroen Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Co-op Insurance

    Ecoinsurance

  • Co-op Insurance

    Young Driver Insurance

  • Countrywide

    Autoline

  • Coverbox

    Car Insurance (AXA)

  • Coverbox

    Car Insurance (Midas)

  • CSIS

    Car Solutions Insurance

  • Debenhams

    Car Insurance (Highway)

  • drive like a girl

    Private Car

  • Drive Smart

    Private Car Insurance

  • Endsleigh

    Motor Insurance

  • ERS

    Private Car

  • Fish Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Forces Mutual

    Forces Insurance Motor Insurance (Ageas)

  • Forces Mutual

    Forces Insurance Motor Insurance (Markerstudy)

  • Forces Mutual

    Private Car (Aviva)

  • Go Girl

    Private Car Insurance

  • Halifax

    Car Insurance

  • Highway Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • iGO4 Insurance

    More Insurance

  • Ingenie Insurance Services

    Car Insurance

  • Insure 2 Drive

    Private Car Insurance

  • Insure The Box Limited

    Private Car

  • Key Choice

    SoteriaDrive

  • Legal & General

    Car Insurance

  • Lifesure Group

    40 Plus Specialist Insurance

  • Lloyds Bank

    Car Insurance

  • Marmalade

    New Driver Insurance

  • MORE TH>N Sm>rt Wheels

    Smart Wheels Car Insurance

  • Nissan Insurance

    Car Insurance (Ageas)

  • Peugeot Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Post Office Money

    Car Insurance (Comparison Site)

  • Post Office Money

    Car Insurance (CTM & Moneysupermarket)

  • Post Office Money

    Under 50s Car Insurance

  • RAC

    Car Insurance

  • Santander

    Car Insurance

  • Seat

    Motor Insurance

  • Skoda

    Motor Insurance

  • Southern Rock Insurance Company

    Private Car Insurance

  • Tesco Bank

    Box Insurance

  • Vauxhall Motors

    Motor Insurance

  • Volkswagen Insurance

    Motor Insurance

  • Volkswagen Insurance

    Motor Insurance (1 year free + telematics)

  • Volkswagen Insurance

    Motor Insurance (1 year free)

  • Volkswagen Insurance

    Motor Insurance (Telematics)

  • Watford Re

    Private Car Insurance

  • Zenith Insurance Plc

    Car Insurance

  • Zurich

    Car Insurance (Broker)

2 Star rated

  • AA

    Get Driving Private Car Insurance

  • BoxyMo.co.uk

    Private Car Policy (NI only)

  • Carrot Insurance

    Better Driver (Alpha)

  • Carrot Insurance

    Better Driver (RSA)

  • Carrot Insurance

    Better Driver (Zurich)

  • Carrot Insurance

    Car Insurance (Ageas)

  • Carrot Insurance

    New Driver (Alpha)

  • Carrot Insurance

    New Driver (Markerstudy)

  • Carrot Insurance

    New Driver (Zurich)

  • Collingwood Insurance

    Young Driver Insurance

  • Cornish Mutual

    Private Motor Vehicle Insurance

  • Eridge Underwriting

    Private Car and Taxi Motor Insurance

  • Hastings Essential

    Car Insurance (Policy Wording Ref HE-PC-CPW)

  • Hastings Essential

    Car Insurance (Policy Wording Ref HE-PC-GW)

  • iGO4 Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • KGM Motor Insurance

    2Infinity Multi Vehicle Insurance

  • KGM Motor Insurance

    Private Car Insurance

  • Markerstudy

    Motor Insurance

  • Markerstudy

    Solar Private Car

  • Midas Underwriting

    Executive Car Insurance (NI only)

  • Midas Underwriting

    Premier Car Insurance (NI only)

  • Midas Underwriting

    Private Car

  • Mulsanne Insurance

    Private Car

  • Nissan Insurance

    Car Insurance (Zenith)

  • Park Home Assist Insurance Services Ltd

    Private Car

  • Performance Direct

    Motor Insurance (MarketPlace)

  • Premier Underwriting Ltd

    Premier TNIA Private Car Policy

  • Swinton

    Essential Car Insurance

  • Tansar

    Private Car

  • Towergate Insurance

    Wheels + Private Car Insurance (Ageas)

  • Towergate Insurance

    Wheels + Private Car Insurance (ERS)

  • Towergate Insurance

    Wheels Private Car Insurance

  • Xpekt

    Private Car Insurance

  • Zenith Insurance Plc

    Bright Box Private Car Insurance Policy

  • Zenith Insurance Plc

    Private Car Insurance

  • Zenith Marque

    Auto-Marque

  • Zenith Marque

    Hi-Marque

1 Star rated

  • China Taiping Insurance

    Private Car Insurance

  • Collingwood Insurance

    Motor Car Insurance

  • Collingwood Insurance

    Private Car Insurance for Learner Drivers

  • Debenhams

    Motor Insurance (XS Direct)

  • Haven Insurance Company Ltd

    Private Car Insurance

  • Haven Insurance Company Ltd

    Private Car Insurance Plus

  • Haven Insurance Company Ltd

    Private Car Insurance Protect

  • iGO4 Insurance

    Essential Insurance

  • Kinetic Insurance Brokers

    Private Car

  • MCE Insurance

    Car Insurance

  • Octane Underwriting

    Motor Insurance

  • Premier Underwriting Ltd

    Premier PICL Private Car Policy

  • Qudos Insurance A/S

    Private Car Insurance

  • Sabre

    Private Car Insurance

  • The Insurance Factory

    Motor Insurance (XS Direct)

  • Trinity Lane Insurance Company

    Trinity Lane Motor Vehicle

  • Walsingham Motor Insurance

    Private Car Insurance

  • Woop Cover

    Car Insurance (Young Drivers)

  • XS Direct Insurance Broker Ltd

    Motor Insurance

  • Zenith Insurance Plc

    Private Car (Distinction IHR)

Related links

   

 

FACTS BEHIND THE RATING

See the features and benefits that make up the 5 Star Car Insurance Rating

 

Learn more

 

   

OUR METHODOLOGY

Our Star Ratings are updated every year on 1 February. Throughout the year we review the criteria with the industry and conduct market research to set robust standards. Our ratings are published here, on our website, ensuring transparency.

 

Learn more